Quranic Sciences: Lectures delivered by Hujjat al-Islam Sayyid Muhammad Baqir al-Hakim

## The Meccan and Medinan Qur’an

The discussion of the **Meccan and Medinan Qur’an** can be divided into three main topics:

1. The meaning of Meccan and Medinan
2. The method of distinguishing between them
3. The doubts raised about this classification

—

# First: The Meaning of Meccan and Medinan

In the terminology of Qur’anic commentators, the Qur’an is divided into **Meccan** and **Medinan**. Some of its verses are Meccan and others are Medinan. Scholars of exegesis have proposed several interpretations of this terminology.

### The First View (The Most Common View)

The most widely accepted interpretation bases the distinction on **chronological order**, taking the **Hijrah (the Prophet’s migration from Mecca to Medina)** as the dividing line between two periods.

– Every verse revealed **before the Hijrah** is considered **Meccan**.
– Every verse revealed **after the Hijrah** is considered **Medinan**, even if its place of revelation was Mecca—such as the verses revealed to the Prophet when he returned to Mecca at the time of the conquest.

Thus, according to this view, **the criterion is time, not place**.

### The Second View

Another interpretation bases the distinction on **location**.

– Any verse revealed while the Prophet was **in Mecca** is considered **Meccan**.
– Any verse revealed while he was **in Medina** is considered **Medinan**.

### The Third View

A third approach bases the distinction on **the audience addressed in the verses**.

– Verses addressing the **people of Mecca** are considered Meccan.
– Verses addressing the **people of Medina** are considered Medinan.

### Comparison of the Three Views

The first approach has an advantage over the other two because it includes **all Qur’anic verses** in one of the two categories.

If we adopt the **chronological criterion**, every verse must be either:

– revealed before the Hijrah (Meccan), or
– revealed after the Hijrah (Medinan).

Even verses revealed during the Prophet’s journey between Mecca and Medina would still fall into one of these two categories based on time.

However, if we rely on **place or audience**, we might encounter verses that are neither Meccan nor Medinan. For example, verses revealed during the **Night Journey (Isrāʾ)** or the **Ascension (Miʿrāj)** did not occur in either city, nor were they directed specifically to the people of Mecca or Medina.

—

# Preference Between the Three Views

When comparing these views, the **third view should be rejected first**, because it is based on an incorrect assumption—that some Qur’anic verses address only the people of Mecca and others only the people of Medina.

In reality, **Qur’anic addresses are universal**. Even if a verse initially applied to the people of Mecca or Medina, this does not mean that its guidance, instruction, or legal rulings were restricted to them.

Furthermore, the terms **Meccan and Medinan are not religious terms defined by the Prophet**. They are simply scholarly conventions adopted by Qur’anic commentators. Therefore, scholars are free to define them according to their chosen criteria.

However, defining these terms **according to chronological order**, as in the first view, is more beneficial for Qur’anic studies than defining them according to location.

The importance of the chronological distinction appears in two major areas:

### 1. Jurisprudential Importance

From a legal perspective, knowing which verses were revealed **before and after the Hijrah** helps identify **abrogation (naskh)**.

Since the abrogating ruling must come **later in time** than the abrogated one, if two rulings conflict, the later (Medinan) verse would naturally abrogate the earlier (Meccan) one.

### 2. Historical Importance

The chronological classification also helps us understand **the stages of the Islamic mission**.

The Hijrah was not merely an incidental event in the history of Islam. It marked a fundamental transition between two stages:

– The stage of **individual preaching**
– The stage of **organized community and state**

By distinguishing verses revealed before and after the Hijrah, we can follow the development of the Islamic call and observe its characteristics in each stage.

In contrast, focusing only on **place of revelation** provides little insight into these stages and may mix them together. It also prevents us from identifying abrogation in legal rulings.

For these reasons, the **first view (the chronological definition)** is preferred, and the terms Meccan and Medinan will be used according to this meaning.

—

# Second: How Meccan and Medinan Verses Are Identified

When scholars first attempted to distinguish between Meccan and Medinan verses, they relied on **historical reports and narrations** that recorded when particular verses or chapters were revealed—whether before or after the Hijrah.

Through these reports, scholars were able to identify many Meccan and Medinan chapters and verses.

After gathering this information, many scholars undertook **comparative studies** of the known Meccan and Medinan passages. From this comparison they identified **general characteristics** common to Meccan verses and others common to Medinan verses.

These characteristics were then used as **guidelines** for classifying verses whose chronological context was not reported.

Some of these characteristics relate to **style**, while others relate to **subject matter**.

### Characteristics Common in Meccan Verses

1. Short verses and chapters with concise expression and strong rhythmic harmony.
2. Emphasis on the fundamentals of faith in God and the Hereafter, and vivid descriptions of Paradise and Hell.
3. Calls to noble moral conduct and righteousness.
4. Arguments against the polytheists and criticism of their beliefs.
5. Frequent use of the address **“O mankind”** rather than **“O you who believe.”**

(It has been observed that **Surah al‑Hajj** is an exception, since it uses the second expression despite being considered Meccan.)

### Characteristics Common in Medinan Verses

1. Longer verses and chapters with more detailed explanation.
2. Detailed arguments and proofs for religious truths.
3. Debates with the **People of the Book** and calls for moderation in religion.
4. Discussion of **hypocrites** and their problems.
5. Detailed legislation concerning punishments, obligations, rights, and social, political, and international laws.

—

# Our Position Regarding These Characteristics

There is no doubt that these characteristics help illuminate the subject and may assist in determining whether a chapter is more likely Meccan or Medinan when no historical report exists.

However, such criteria should only be relied upon when they produce **certainty**.

For example, if a chapter resembles Meccan chapters in brevity, style, and criticism of polytheists, it may **likely** be Meccan. But probability alone is not sufficient, because a Medinan chapter could sometimes share stylistic features of Meccan ones.

Therefore, reliance on these criteria is acceptable only when they lead to **strong confidence** about the historical context.

For instance, verses dealing with **laws of warfare or state governance** clearly belong to the Medinan period, since such legislation could not have appeared during the early Meccan stage when the Muslim community had not yet established a state.

—

# Third: Doubts Raised About the Meccan and Medinan Distinction

The topic of Meccan and Medinan verses has also been the subject of criticism and doubt. Some Orientalists have argued that the differences between the Meccan and Medinan parts of the Qur’an suggest that the Qur’an was influenced by varying social and personal circumstances affecting its style and content.

Before addressing these doubts, two important points should be noted.

### First Point

We must distinguish between two ideas:

– The idea that the Qur’an **was influenced and shaped by its surrounding circumstances**, which would imply that it is a human product.
– The idea that the Qur’an **took those circumstances into account in order to guide and transform them**.

The first idea assumes that the Qur’an simply reflects its environment. The second recognizes that the Qur’an aims to **change reality**, and therefore its method and style may vary according to the objectives it seeks to achieve.

There is a major difference between circumstances **imposing themselves on the message** and the message **adapting its method to achieve its goals within those circumstances**.

### Second Point

When explaining any Qur’anic phenomenon, we must consider **the true origin of the Qur’an itself**.

The Qur’an is not the personal product of Muhammad nor a purely human work. Rather, it is **a divine revelation connected with heaven**.

From this perspective, the doubts raised about the Meccan and Medinan distinction become invalid, because they are based on the assumption that the Qur’an is a human composition.

In reality, these doubts are closely connected to broader objections raised against **revelation itself**. Therefore, they must be examined in that wider context in order to clarify their invalidity and provide the correct explanation for the differences between the Meccan and Medinan sections of the Qur’an.

Check Also

Parables in the Holy Quran are a source of divine guidance. 5

Fifteenth: Alid Parables The Commander of the Faithful, Imam ʿAli (peace be upon him), was …